Man Sues OpenAI After ChatGPT Allegedly Told Him Not to See a Doctor

OpenAI is being sued by former Florida pastor Scott Winters after claiming that ChatGPT advised him against seeking medical attention. The negligence and unauthorized medical practice lawsuit was filed in the San Francisco Superior Court on July 22 by Winters who blames ChatGPT for a life-threatening pulmonary embolism. The complaint alleges that OpenAI and its CEO Sam Altman are responsible for a series of events that led to Winters’s bilateral pulmonary embolism.

The allegations

The plaintiff alleges that over the course of several months, he sought medical advice from ChatGPT-4o, an AI chatbot that started downplaying the severity of his condition. The complaint indicates that the chatbot reduced his symptoms, including the dizziness and groin discomfort that prompted him to go to the hospital.

It also mentions that he was manipulated into thinking that there was no need to go to the hospital by the use of language that appealed to his religious beliefs. Winters was later admitted to the hospital with a bilateral pulmonary embolism after being encouraged to remain inactive for an extended period of time.

ChatGPT is not meant to replace a medical professional, OpenAI responded to the accusations. They further claimed that the choices made by Winters and his family could not be controlled by the chatbot and that there are numerous variables to consider when making medical treatments.

Why there is significance in this case

The case’s significance goes beyond Winters’s damage claim; it also seeks to have ChatGPT Health suspended until OpenAI finishes undergoing a safety certification by an independent organization.

Additionally, it brings up the issue of whether medical AI assistants should be subject to the same FDA regulations as conventional medical devices. If the courts rule in a certain way, it could have an impact on the development of consumer-facing AI products and how they are marketed in relation to medical services. By highlighting the difficulties in distinguishing between conversation and medical practice, the case will have an impact on the healthcare sector.

The lawsuit against OpenAI highlights the challenges that the law faces in keeping up with technology developments. While regulators have been hesitant to restrict AI health assistants, considering them to be informational aids, numerous legal experts believe that the personalization of medical recommendations may constitute medical practice. The outcome of the case is still unknown, although it could have an impact on how medical chatbots operate, what disclosures they make, and what precautions they take while speaking with users who are experiencing potentially dangerous conditions.

Get the latest tech news on WhatsApp